Alpha Dog Training: Antiquated or Still Relevant?

Trainers, Subscribe, and weigh in!

Performing a quick search on Google may lead you to think that the alpha approach to animal behavioral training is harsh and outdated. While some variations of this approach may indeed fall into that category, could it be that the idea of "alpha" itself is simply considered distasteful and out of style among the "intelligenciq?" Well, we kinda think so, but love our dogs and your dogs enough to remain objective on the matter, and consider both arguments.

It's important to note that the majority of trainers who continue to employ the alpha method are caring individuals who love dogs and abhor animal cruelty as much as anyone. While this may not always be the case, based on our interactions with many, many trainers, we'll go out on a limb by stating that it is generally true.

The concept of "alpha" remains prominent in various scientific fields including evolutionary biology, anthropology, psychology, and others. It is not simply disregarded as a negative human construct. "Alpha dog training" follows the school of thought that dogs, like wolves, operate within a strict social hierarchy where one individual is the dominant leader, or "alpha." This approach suggests that dog owners must establish themselves as the alpha to maintain control and ensure obedience. However, the relevance and effectiveness of this method are subjects of ongoing debate among dog trainers and behaviorists.

Well, we want to settle the issue right here.

Arguments for Alpha Dog Training Being Antiquated

• Outdated Research: The alpha theory originates from studies on captive wolf packs, which have since been criticized for not accurately representing natural wolf behavior. Wild wolf packs are typically family units led by parents, not a single dominant alpha.

• Potential for Negative Effects: Techniques associated with alpha training, such as dominance-based corrections, can lead to fear, anxiety, and aggression in dogs if applied improperly or in excess.

• Shift to Positive Reinforcement: Many trainers advocate for ONLY positive reinforcement methods, which focus on rewarding desired behaviors rather than punishing unwanted ones. This approach is considered by most professionals to be much more effective in building a trusting relationship between owner and dog.

Arguments for Alpha Dog Training Still Being Relevant

• Clear Boundaries: Some proponents argue that establishing clear boundaries and leadership can help prevent behavioral issues by providing structure and consistency.

• Specific Situations: In certain cases, elements of alpha training may be beneficial for dogs exhibiting dominance-related behavior problems. However, these should be applied by or under the the guidance of a professional trainer.

Conclusion

Well, it's not really a conclusion, since we hope to keep the conversation going on our blawg. But some trainers have expressed a balanced approach, combining elements of alpha training, while showing preference to positive reinforcement to address specific behaviors. And that sounds pretty sensible!

Good Dog Bad Dawg remains open on the subject, and invite professionals to weigh in.

Pete McConnell

Founder